Showing posts with label confirmation bias. Show all posts
Showing posts with label confirmation bias. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 February 2018

Another Mel Gibson Christ movie?

The first one was a big hit at the box office. There was scarcely a Christian who didn't pay to see something they already believed in -- it certainly didn't contain any new information. There's good ol' confirmation bias, the consumption of something vapid because we already knw what it'll say. And a feeling of validation. A big budget Hollywood production that treats a pet belief of many as real history will make Christians feel they're not swivel-eyed lunatics; that they belong; that they're part of mainstream culture. That same dynamic will apply second time around about the alleged resurrection. It's sad because it'll be a thought terminating device. The cultural validation these films give Christians acts as a way to stave off doing any textual criticism. It'll definitely make money.

There are obviously contradictions in the resurrection stories. Other people have covered that well enough:

http://www.patheos.com/blogs/crossexamined/2012/04/contradictions-in-the-resurrection-account-2/

So we must wait with some curiosity to see which way the film leans on these contradictions. If it were me, I'd have second thoughts about making the resurrection seem like historical fact when it's more reasonable to conclude it isn't. Surely in trying to write a coherent script someone is going to lose their faith? Can we hope?

    

Wednesday, 31 January 2018

The best new theist book or argument?

I've seen a Catholic ask the reverse about new atheist books, so it's a fair question. Theists of course do so as a prelude to dismissing all new atheist books as not worth the time to read them. Confirmation bias.

But what would a new book on creationism even look like? The memoirs of Ken Ham? It's been a while since any new philosophical argument for God was proposed, and even then, arguing the existence of "a deity" is not quite the same as a rigorous and scientific demonstration that the particularly Roman Catholic god is the true one. This is not even the same god as the Protestant one. --The Catholic one sent Jesus to die, but thousands of years later still isn't sure why that had to happen. After all justification isn't by faith, it's by baptism. Sanctifying grace is drip fed through the sacraments ex opere operato, and the perfect innocence of Jesus isn't imputed to Catholics either (and definitely not through faith), so they have to go through Purgatory. The substitutionary death of Christ (and that's clearly how the story is intended, fictional as it may be) has no place in Catholicism. This is an entirely different plan to the god of Protestants. So if a Catholic philosopher / theologian were to come up with a book that "proved" the existence of God... which god? If a Protestant philosopher / theologian had a book that proved the existence of God... which god?

None of these arguments for the plausibility of a deity gives us access to the mind and personality and objectives of that deity. The grounds for believing any particular religion is still zero.

Monday, 29 January 2018

Feser's double standards

Ed Feser is a name I've come across in the past, and out of curiosity I googled and found his blog. A post that mentioned "New Atheism" was catnip to me, and I could not but help wondering how a known polemicist like him would calmly deal with it.

In that post he links to a review of a book called Faith versus Fact by Jerry Coyne. As book reviews go it's little more than a hasty smear job. We know from the start that some readers of such books aren't saying in their minds "okay, convince me" but actively looking for things to complain about. I'm sure Feser has had atheists read his books like that too. A whole gaggle of cognitive biases are protecting us from questioning deeply held beliefs.

It's a case of dramatic irony that Feser titles his review "An Omnibus of Fallacies". I'm sure he means the book, not his own review of it.

Example 1.
When churchmen refuse to abandon some doctrine, Coyne tells us that this shows that religion is dogmatic and unwilling to adjust itself to modern knowledge. When churchmen do abandon some doctrine, Coyne tells us that this shows that religion is unfalsifiable and desperate to adjust itself to modern knowledge. It seems Coyne also missed that lecture in logic class about the fallacy of special pleading.
No, Feser that's called a dilemma, not special pleading. And it's not a dilemma for Coyne, it's one for you. Religions are slow to adjust to modern knowledge. For centuries, geocentricism was believed - the cosmology in the Bible is a flat earth snow globe, stars were in the solid sky above earth and even the god of the Bible has that view - and when more and greater knowledge of how the cosmos was actually arranged there was some cognitive dissonance that took some time to reconcile. It undermined the religions that had "known" geocentricism was true because of what unreliable holy texts said. What is true, and even how we know what is true, became a live issue. Eventually the cognitive dissonance was resolved by reducing the importance of geocentricism to religion. Oh the churchmen may have rearranged their thoughts to their satisfaction, but outsiders have every right to call them out on that change in doctrine and ask why it doesn't falsify the religion. That's the dilemma. This is Sagan's "dragon in my garage" all over. We know, empirically, the visible institution that calls itself the Roman Catholic Church is neither unified, nor holy, nor demonstrably apostolic in it's doctrines. Yet no amount of disunity, of evil, of doctrinal accretions unknown in the first 1000 years of it's history counts against the magnificent Roman Catholic Church as one, holy, and apostolic. That's what unfalsifiable looks like. If your religion is true, then you can't have it both ways. Either dogmatically cling to geocentricism and flat earth nonsense and Noah's ark and die on that hill for that belief, or adjust to modern knowledge and accept that it falsifies your religion. Feser and believers like him want us to respect religion even as it vacillates in the face of actual empirical evidence, which at no point can call into question the impervious idealized religion he holds.    

Example 2.
... Nor is “religion” the only term Coyne uses in a tendentious way. The question-begging definition is perhaps his favorite debating trick. He characterizes “faith” as “belief without—or in the face of—evidence” and repeatedly uses the term as if this is what it generally means in religious contexts. Naturally, he has no trouble showing that faith so understood is irrational. But this simply is not how faith is understood historically in Christian theology. For example, for scholastic theologians, faith is assent to something that has been revealed by God. And how do we know that God exists and really has revealed it? Those are claims for which, the theologian agrees, evidence needs to be given.
That's half a dozen fallacies. Feser is equivocating. So instead of saying as Coyne does that "faith is believing something [without evidence]", now faith is "assent to something [revealed by God]" -- those bracketed clauses are equivalent. Lets not kid ourselves, "revealed by God" is a faith claim for which there is probably no evidence. And if we take him at his word, presumably Feser doesn't give religiously assent to anything he can't prove was revealed by God. He must believe very little.

So Feser might say faith is assent to dogmas like the Immaculate Conception, but believing the content of that proposition does nothing to address the epistemological question of how-do-you-know-it's-true? Any grain of intellectual honesty should be enough for him to admit there are many things, many of these supposed divine revelations, that he takes on faith - no more than an ipse dixit table thump from Rome. Which is of course ironic when he recoils at being painted with that brush by Coyne. "No!", says Feser. "Of course we agree we need evidence for what we believe! That is not in dispute!" Really? How far may I prod your beliefs before you run out of evidence and all you have is hearsay? This is exactly Coyne's point. As a Catholic, Feser must perforce believe in just the manner Coyne says.

This type of thinking is what chips away at the faith of rational, critical thinking people who observe quietly from a distance. Seeing theologians, and ministers, and bishops, and religious philosophers lack any self-awareness, seeing them defend the faith with double standards and lack of clarity.


Thursday, 25 January 2018

Making the data fit the theory

"It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data. Insensibly one begins to twist facts to suit theories, instead of theories to suit facts." - Sherlock Holmes in A Scandal in Bohemia

I'll respond to some problems of rational thought in this. He does nail the draw of Catholicism. The social stability is a huge part of it.

https://medium.com/@MatthewSchultz/why-stay-protestant-435b5e1006a0

But first it's worth saying why such a piece interests me.

I grew up Protestant. Specifically in the fairly liturgical Church of England in South Africa (lately renamed to REACH: Reformed Evangelical Anglican Church of Southern Africa) that, when my father leads the service at least, still uses the Prayer Book - analogous to a Catholic missal. The type you'll find in the pews is the soft cover variety, but on a book shelf close by is my very own Prayer Book in hard cover form, probably signed by the bishop. (I'm guessing. I don't really care enough to look. These are my confessions.) It's still a pretty Thing, either way. My family at various times have wished I'd go into the ministry.

On the Catholic side, some of my constant friends through childhood (not that religion was ever discussed) were Catholics. Nay, even more: they are SSPX Catholics. Some years later, and through these friends, I got to know a girl who is also SSPX. With a crazy and beautiful sense of humour with whom I could share my latent interest in growing roses and Gilbert & Sullivan and everything else besides, without it being weird. So the Catholic question became important to me. By this time I had already completed my degree in philosophy, and despite that equipping me with good mental tools I was still naïve and uncritical of my religion and loyally Protestant. I literally didn't even know that Catholics think their church was founded on Peter. (As an aside, Catholics catastrophically fail to understand the concept of the Church as Protestants do. For what it's worth, the Protestant doctrine is more biblical. But that's a vacuous truth that amounts to no more than being right about Dickens' use of the Meagles family in Little Dorrit.)

The above link is therefore interesting to me. It's a debate I'm familiar with. I'm curious to see how other Protestants, though I no longer identify as one, deal with Catholicism; and how they rationalize being Christian.

------

From the link above, this is what intellectual dishonesty looks like:
... As a Protestant, I have two basic options when informing my study of the Bible. The first is consulting scholars who think the text is inspired and more or less inerrant. This comes with arguments or assumptions about the nature and quality of the Bible’s authorship: Matthew really did write Matthew, the disciples' memory of Jesus’s teachings is entirely or almost entirely accurate, Jesus really did make accurate prophecies, he really did miracles as described, and so forth.

The other option is consulting scholars who doubt or actively disbelieve all of the above propositions. They approach the text with a hermeneutic of suspicion. They doubt Matthew wrote Matthew. They doubt Jesus said and taught everything ascribed to him. Many claim that Jesus’s teachings were issued as a fallible man: given perhaps as a (mostly) good man, but certainly not as a divinely inspired God-man.

When it comes to Catholicism, most or all of the NT Catholic scholars I’m aware of fall somewhere in the second camp. Why would I follow a denomination that approves of or passes over scholars within its own ranks that seem to deny or doubt the reliability and authority of the Bible on such a regular basis? ...
If we look at the comment on the authorship of Matthew, as one example, see how that just begs the question: how does anyone come to this view of the Bible absent any textual criticism? Is it rational to collect all the thousands of religious writings from all ages and all cultures, put a blindfold on, choose one, and then cling to it as "the Truth"? Surely not. So by what principle should anyone believe the authority of the Bible if not through the means here rejected? What if in the structure of the text we see telltale signs that it isn't real history? The mentality quoted above reminds me of Aquinas, and Bertrand Russell's critique of him:
He does not, like the Platonic Socrates, set out to follow wherever the argument may lead. He is not engaged in an inquiry, the result of which it is impossible to know in advance. 
Why listen to scholars who question the Bible? Because that's what curiosity is. Because that's the only way to know if you're throwing you life away believing a lie or not. Because if truth matters we don't presume we know everything and stick out fingers in our ears to block out anything that contradicts it. I can assure all believers that groups like the Branch Davidians or the Mormons also said and say among themselves "why would I follow anyone that questions the authority of what I know is true?" It's transparent confirmation bias: I'll only listen to those who agree with me. Yeah, but what if you're wrong?

If we want to believe more right things and fewer wrong things we don't start with the theory, we start with the data. And that's why scholars who don't presume the conclusion at the start are worth listening to.